During the 2024 election season, Americans were inundated with media stereotypes, fearmongering, and increased polarization, to name a few. Although Christian Nationalism is widely reported in American media, in a national survey we conducted with Technites, we found that very few Americans identify with this term. Only 5% of our sample self-reported as ever having identified themselves as a Christian Nationalist or sympathizing with Christian Nationalism as a movement. 

 

A growing misconception is that Christian nationalists are synonymous with Republicans, but our study reports that only 17% of those identifying as Republicans or leaning Republican are classified as a CN Adherent. Ryan Burge, a leading expert in data analysis concerning religion and politics nationwide, reported that “[w]hile the most public facing expressions of Christian Nationalism tend to come from members of the GOP, there is a significant contingent of Americans who embrace that tenets of Christian Nationalism without embracing the Republican Party.” In fact, around half of CN Adherents feel Republicans are a threat to the United States (50%), are downright evil (58%), and [lack] the traits to be fully human (47%). Christian Nationalism is best characterized as a collection of related beliefs and attitudes—less so as a dogmatic worldview or holistic personal identity, which highlights its complexity.

 

This distinction between misconception versus reality matters in (1) knowing our neighbors, which in turn promotes empathy and fosters inclusive communities rather than simplistic labels that overgeneralize and increase polarization; (2) bridging divides by recognizing diversity within groups and fostering constructive dialogue; and (3) challenging stereotypes, which encourages more critical thinking and open-minded interactions about political and religious ideologies. 

 

How do we actually live this out? Practically speaking, look for common ground and shared values when interacting with people who hold different political or religious views. Also, lean into community. Make an effort to get to know your neighbors regardless of their political or religious beliefs. Collaboration is better than isolation. Lastly, and most importantly, maintain a faithful Christian witness marked by integrity. Kaitlyn Scheiss, in her article entitled “Pastors: Model Faithful Christian Witness in Public” in our executive report, writes, “While church leaders can learn to articulate nuanced criticisms of Christian Nationalism, it is much more important that they describe and model faithful Christian witness in public.” Instead of getting caught up in debates or political categorizations, lead by example in your community and demonstrate Christian values through actions, not just words. 

 

True Christian witness comes from living out authentic faith rather than simply aligning with a political movement. By focusing on living out Christ’s teachings in your daily life and in your interactions with others, you can create a more meaningful impact that transcends political divisions, inspiring others to contribute toward a more compassionate and inclusive society.